Understanding MMT and Opportunity Cost: A Friendly Rebuttal
Recently, I came across an article by John Q titled "Opportunity cost, MMT and public spending." While the author presents a thought-provoking analysis, I believe that a few key points from the Modern Monetary Theory (MMT) perspective deserve further clarification. In this blog post, I aim to provide a friendly rebuttal to some of the arguments presented by John Q and explain how MMT and opportunity cost can complement each other.
MMT and the Concept of Opportunity Cost
First and foremost, it's important to emphasise that MMT proponents do not dismiss the importance of opportunity cost. MMT seeks to provide a better understanding of the true constraints on government spending, which are not financial but rather tied to real resources—such as labour, materials, and productive capacity.
MMT acknowledges that the primary role of taxation is to manage aggregate demand (outside of establishing currency use), ensuring the economy operates at full capacity without causing inflation.
However, we must recognise that our current economic system often fails to utilise its full potential. Unemployment, underemployment, and idle resources are not uncommon, particularly during economic recessions or crises.
In these situations, MMT suggests that additional government spending can help mobilise underutilised resources without causing inflation, thereby improving overall well-being.
The Misconception of Unlimited Spending
John Q's article raises the concern that some MMT proponents may believe governments can spend money on anything they like without the need for increased taxes or cuts in other spending areas.
It's crucial to clarify that this is not a mainstream MMT view.
Responsible MMT advocates understand that decisions about spending priorities and taxation policies should be grounded in economic and social goals, as well as the availability of real resources.
MMT is not a license for unlimited spending; it's a framework for understanding the true limits and potential of public spending.
Debt Cancellation and Opportunity Cost
The author also discusses the opportunity cost of debt cancellation policies, arguing that increased taxes on the wealthy or reduced spending in other areas (such as the military) would be necessary to offset the policy's impacts. While it's true that some redistribution may be required to prevent inflation, we should also consider the broader benefits of such policies.
Debt cancellation could lead to increased economic activity as relieved individuals spend more, invest in their futures, and contribute to overall growth. This increased economic activity could, in turn, generate higher tax revenues and offset some of the costs associated with the policy.
Moreover, the opportunity cost argument assumes that there's always a clear and undisputed best alternative use of funds. In reality, this is often not the case, as different groups have divergent priorities and values.
MMT helps us understand that the primary constraint on public spending is not an arbitrary budget figure but rather real resources and productive capacity. This understanding enables a more informed and nuanced debate about spending priorities and the true opportunity costs of different policies.
MMT and Opportunity Cost: Complementary Perspectives
Overall, I believe that MMT and the concept of opportunity cost can coexist and complement each other in shaping responsible fiscal policy. By understanding the real constraints on public spending, we can make more informed decisions about allocating resources to best serve society's needs.
Achieve Financial and Mental Wellness
Looking for effective resources to help overcome financial stress and anxious thoughts? This subscription has you covered.
As a paying subscriber, gain unlimited access to 5 powerful tools absolutely free:
A comprehensive eBook guides transforming your finances through proven habits and strategies.
4 Anxiety-Busting wall posters that provide techniques to quiet worried thoughts and build resilience. Great for personal or professional use!
Whether you seek tools for personal growth or your mental health practice, these science-backed resources can significantly boost well-being over the long run.
Subscribe now to empower yourself and your clients with an all-inclusive wellness toolkit. Finally, take command of money mindsets and unlock healthier, wealthier lives for all. Your future of financial peace and mental ease is just a click away!
If you enjoyed this post, please consider buying me a coffee by pressing the button below.