Capping Interest Rates and Freezing Rents
A Necessary Step for Housing Affordability Amid Escalating Crisis
The housing crisis has become a defining issue for many Australians, as skyrocketing rents and unreachable homeownership dreams continue to affect our communities. A shocking new report by Anglicare reveals that less than one per cent of available rental properties across the country are affordable for a person working on a minimum wage, marking the worst result ever seen. In this dire situation, those on Centrelink payments "don't even stand a chance," according to Anglicare Australia Executive Director Kasy Chambers.
One such individual facing the brunt of the crisis is a 39-year-old disabled woman from Sydney, who is struggling to find a suitable home. She currently lives in an overpriced one-bedroom granny flat that is not suitable for her needs. She says, "There's a steep gravel walkway - I have mobility challenges - and the bathroom is so small that the door doesn't open wide enough to get a shower stool in there. There's an issue with landlords conducting repairs in a timely manner. I was without a cooking method for over a year, the front door can't be locked from the exterior, and the showerhead broke a week after moving in and still hasn't been repaired."
"For people like me, whose rent is more than 75% of my income, how am I supposed to save up to provide months of rent upfront?"
The woman has been searching for a new house, but there are almost no affordable options. She adds, "Suitability is still an issue, and these properties are still miles away from my healthcare providers. There are images of these properties showing their need for repairs, kitchen cabinet doors falling off the hinges, lack of silicone around sinks and bathtubs, damage to the exterior of the oven, some are clearly filthy."
The woman is also concerned about the number of agents asking for months of rent upfront. She says, "For people like me, whose rent is more than 75% of my income, how am I supposed to save up to provide months of rent upfront?"
In response to the worsening crisis and the plight of individuals like the woman from Sydney, the Greens have recently proposed legislation aimed at capping interest rates and freezing rents, a move that has sparked a heated debate about the rights and duties of stakeholders involved in the housing market.
“While full-time essential workers can't afford to rent a home, the prime minister is sitting back collecting $115,000 a year from his multiple investment properties and leaving desperate renters to fend for themselves.”
- Greens housing spokesman Max Chandler-Mather
Greens housing spokesman Max Chandler-Mather pointed out that several states during the worst of the COVID-19 pandemic introduced rent controls.
He criticized the prime minister, saying, "While full-time essential workers can't afford to rent a home, the prime minister is sitting back collecting $115,000 a year from his multiple investment properties and leaving desperate renters to fend for themselves."
Greens treasury spokesman Nick McKim highlighted the plight of renters and mortgage holders, stating that they were getting "smashed" by cost of living pressures.
"Labor's inaction on rents and interest rates is making the housing crisis worse," Senator McKim said, adding that "The Greens bill is a concrete plan to provide relief for skyrocketing housing costs whether they be driven by interest rates or rents."
While some argue that such measures would infringe upon property owners' rights and the central bank's independence, it is essential to consider the broader implications of the housing crisis on society. By prioritizing the right to affordable housing and fulfilling the government's duty to address this critical issue, implementing interest rate caps and rent freezes is a necessary step towards a more equitable housing landscape.
From a results perspective, capping interest rates and freezing rents would benefit renters and taxpayers by providing relief from escalating housing costs. On the other hand, property owners and the Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) would experience potential harm in the form of reduced rental income and loss of so-called independence, respectively. However, the consequences faced by property owners and the RBA must be weighed against the broader societal benefits of increased housing affordability and reduced financial strain on taxpayers.
When considering the rights and responsibilities of all stakeholders, the government has a duty to address the housing crisis and ensure that Australians have access to affordable housing. While property owners have the right to derive income from their investments, this should not come at the expense of renters' right to stable and reasonably priced housing. Furthermore, the RBA's so-called independence should not supersede the government's duty to act in the best interest of its citizens.
The principle of consistency, invites us to consider how both alternatives treat stakeholders. Implementing interest rate caps and rent freezes would treat property owners differently by limiting their ability to set rents. However, not taking action to address housing affordability would treat renters unfairly by leaving them vulnerable to ever-increasing housing costs.
Given the analysis, the decision to implement legislation capping interest rates and freezing rents is morally well-founded. To ensure a smooth and effective implementation, the government should draft legislation, engage stakeholders for consultation and feedback, amend the legislation based on input, introduce the legislation to parliament, and monitor its impact on the housing market.
Ultimately, the long-term goal should be to review and update housing policies that address affordability and supply issues while establishing ongoing collaboration between the government,property owners, and renters. This could include investing in social housing, providing incentives for building and/or retrofitting affordable housing, and implementing policies that promote a fair balance between the rights and duties of all stakeholders in the housing market.
The housing crisis in Australia has reached an alarming level, with dire consequences for the most vulnerable members of society. Implementing interest rate caps and rent freezes is a necessary step towards addressing the crisis and ensuring that all Australians have access to affordable housing. It is crucial for the government to prioritize the well-being of its citizens and to take decisive action in the face of this critical issue. By doing so, we can work towards a more equitable and inclusive housing landscape for all Australians.
If you enjoyed this post, please consider buying me a coffee by pressing the button below.
Each morning, The Sample delivers one compelling article tailored to your interests. The Sample scours blogs and newsletters to find the most insightful content on the topics you care about, then send you the best article to read with your coffee. If you enjoy what you read, you can subscribe to the writer or publication with one click.
The Sample is your daily window into the ideas and conversations shaping the world. Let us be your bespoke guide to the internet—sign up now to start reading.