As a self-identified MMT economist (not formally trained), I agree with the call for tax reform in Australia put forward by Ben Oquist in his article in the Financial Review. However, I must clarify that Modern Monetary Theory (MMT) does not support abandoning taxes or neglecting their importance in the economy. Rather, MMT emphasizes the need for taxes to be used strategically to regulate the economy, prevent inflation, and promote social justice.
The priority for an MMT economist is to emphasize the need for government spending to be directed towards productive, socially beneficial purposes. We recognize that the government's ability to spend is not constrained by tax revenue, but by the availability of real resources in the economy. Therefore, government spending should be directed towards programs that create jobs, promote sustainable development, and provide essential services to the public.
In the current context of the pandemic, this means that governments should prioritize spending on public health, education, and infrastructure. By investing in these areas, governments can create jobs and build a stronger, more resilient economy that will benefit everyone in the long run.
The next priority for an MMT economist is to strategically employ taxes. Let me be clear: taxes do not fund government spending. However, they do play a critical role in regulating the economy. By curtailing the purchasing power of the private sector, taxes can help to control inflation and ensure that resources are available for government spending. The tax rate structure also serves as an automatic stabilizer in the economy. During a recession, reduced incomes for individuals and businesses lead to lower tax revenues and payments. This automatic reduction in tax revenue helps to offset the decline in economic activity, reducing the need for spending cuts or tax hikes. Conversely, during an economic expansion, tax revenues typically increase as incomes rise, thus preventing overheating and promoting stability and growth. The tax rate structures are paramount to achieving economic stability and growth.
Moreover, taxes can be used to promote social justice by reducing income and wealth inequality. This is a crucial consideration, as a fair and equitable society is necessary for sustainable and inclusive economic growth. Therefore, utilizing taxes strategically is critical for achieving our economic and social goals.
There are many ways that taxes can be used in a strategic manner. For example, progressive income taxes can help reduce income inequality by ensuring that those who can afford to pay more do so. Similarly, taxes on carbon emissions can help reduce greenhouse gas emissions and promote sustainable development. And taxes on luxury goods can help reduce conspicuous consumption and promote a more equitable distribution of resources.
MMT offers a different policy framework that focuses on specific bottlenecks in industries rather than tracking changes in a general price index. Many MMT economists propose a mixture of policy instruments, including tightening environmental and other forms of regulation, strengthening automatic fiscal stabilizers like a Job Guarantee, and introducing new tax brackets to manage inflationary risks. They conclude that a Green Transition can be achieved with the right policy tools and a more nuanced approach to demand management, not taxes alone as they are not the only tool in the toolbox.
Clarifying that MMT does not support abandoning taxes nor neglecting their importance in the economy is also important. MMT recognizes the importance of taxes as a tool for regulating the economy and promoting social justice. However, we also recognize that taxes should not be used as a means of funding government spending, as this can lead to unnecessary austerity measures and harm the economy.
This is a key distinction between MMT and the mainstream economic theory that has dominated policy-making for the past several decades. Mainstream economics has emphasized the need for balanced budgets and deficit reduction, often at the expense of public services and social welfare programs. MMT, on the other hand, recognizes that government spending can be used to achieve social and economic goals, and that taxes should be used to regulate the economy and promote social justice.
In the context of climate change, MMT has an important role to play in promoting sustainable development. Governments must shift their priorities from subsidizing the environmentally unsustainable fossil fuel industry towards investing in renewable energy, battery storage, and electric cars to create jobs, reduce greenhouse gas emissions, and promote a more sustainable and equitable economy.
To achieve a Green Transition, it is crucial to utilize a range of policy instruments, such as tightening environmental regulations to reduce carbon emissions, strengthening automatic fiscal stabilizers like a Job Guarantee to ensure a smooth labor market transition, and introducing new tax brackets to manage inflationary risks. These policies should be integrated and coordinated to achieve common goals.
Overall, MMT emphasizes the need for productive, socially beneficial government spending, strategic use of taxes to regulate the economy and promote social justice, and a nuanced approach to demand management. By adopting a comprehensive and coordinated policy approach, we can achieve a Green Transition that benefits everyone and promotes sustainable development.
If you enjoyed this post, please consider buying me a coffee by pressing the button below.
Sociocultural Australis is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.
Each morning, The Sample delivers one compelling article tailored to your interests. The Sample scours blogs and newsletters to find the most insightful content on the topics you care about, then send you the best article to read with your coffee. If you enjoy what you read, you can subscribe to the writer or publication with one click.
The Sample is your daily window into the ideas and conversations shaping the world. Let us be your bespoke guide to the internet—sign up now to start reading.